What's wrong with women being locked up for 261 days? Why?
Original title: what's wrong with women being locked up for 261 days? Why are they locked up?
What's wrong with a woman being locked for 261 days? What's wrong with her? The law is just. It won't let go of any bad person or wronged any good person. But recently, some women have been locked for 261 days by mistake. Are you shocked to see the news? Let's have a look at the specific situation!
What's wrong with a woman being locked up for 261 days
On November 22, Liu Suxia, who opened a grocery store in Shangshui County, Zhoukou City, Henan Province, filled out the application for state compensation accompanied by a lawyer. She claimed a total of 867570.29 yuan from the Public Security Bureau of Shangshui county and the people's Procuratorate of Shangshui county.
On March 15, 2016, Liu Suxia had a conflict with his neighbor Wu Mou's (pseudonym) family due to trivial matters. Later, Wu Mou accused Liu Suxia of causing personal injury by using his past fracture injury. Since August 15, 2016, the Public Security Bureau of Shangshui county and the people's Procuratorate of Shangshui county have successively made decisions on Liu Suxia's detention and arrest. On September 28, 2017, the court of Shangshui County formally issued to her a "decision on handling the case according to withdrawal", which had previously been wrongly closed for 261 days.
On November 28, Liu Suxia told reporters that in addition to applying for state compensation, she also hoped to investigate the responsibility of the investigators according to law, and let Wu and his family pay the price for the false accusation and frame up.
Why is it locked up
Liu Suxia, a self-employed business owner in Shangshui County, Zhoukou City, has opened a grocery store for tobacco, wine and non-staple food. According to her, she has always had problems with one of her neighbors, Wu, who runs a restaurant. On March 15, 2016, there was a fierce conflict between the two men over trivial matters. After mediation by the police, the two families went to Zhoukou eye hospital and Zhoukou Central Hospital for medical treatment and injury identification. Liu Suxia's eye was injured in the conflict, which was identified as a minor injury by Zhoukou eye hospital. On April 16, 2016, when Liu Suxia went to the police station to inquire about the progress of the case, she was told that 'Wu's right hand fracture was identified as a minor injury grade II. On August 15, 2016, the Public Security Bureau of Shangshui county held Liu Suxia in criminal detention on suspicion of intentional injury, and on August 30, it was changed to bail pending trial.
'I protested to the police at that time, because I heard that Wu had a hand fracture caused by wrestling on an electric car during the Spring Festival. Her hand fracture should be an old injury. What's more, I didn't hit her at all that day. After the dispute happened, she could play with her mobile phone flexibly and freely!' Liu Suxia thought that Wu colluded with the hospital's people to give false evidence, disguised the old injury as a new injury and framed her. Therefore, she entrusted her family to go to Zhoukou central hospital where Wu went to see a doctor to transfer out the medical image data taken by Wu on that day, and in late August 2016, she went to Shangshui county hospital and Shanghai East China Hospital for identification. The diagnosis opinions of both said that 'the middle and far end of the fifth metacarpal bone fracture of the right hand has callus formation'. Liu Suxia believes that Wu's fracture is an old injury, but the commercial water police do not recognize it.
Before that, the Shangshui County Public Security Bureau entrusted the forensic doctors of Shangshui county and Zhoukou City Public Security Bureau to carry out injury identification on Wu's fracture. Although the two forensic identification results both confirmed that Wu's hand injury was objective, they did not show that the injury was caused by Liu Suxia. Therefore, on August 30, 2016, the people's Procuratorate of Shangshui county did not approve the arrest of Liu Suxia by the Public Security Bureau, The supplementary investigation outline for cases of disapproval of arrest was issued.
After that, the Public Security Bureau of Shangshui County entrusted the imaging experts of Henan people's hospital to make identification, and the experts finally determined that the fracture of Wu's right hand was a fresh fracture. Approved by the people's Procuratorate of Shangshui County on November 10, 2016, on November 11, 2016, the Public Security Bureau of Shangshui County arrested Liu Suxia on suspicion of intentional injury, and transferred him to the people's Court of Shangshui County on December 15, 2016 for examination and prosecution.
During the trial of this case, because of the constant appeal of Liu Suxia's family, the people's Court of Shangshui County finally agreed to entrust Beijing Mingzheng judicial appraisal center to reevaluate Wu's fracture. On June 27, 2017, Beijing Mingzheng judicial appraisal center issued the appraisal opinion: 'the healing process of the fracture seen in the imaging of Wu XX on March 15, 2016 does not conform to the clinical healing characteristics of the fresh fracture formed by the trauma on that day, which should be the old fracture'. On July 14, the people's Court of Shangshui county made a decision on Liu Suxia's bail pending trial. On the same day, Liu Suxia was released home. On September 28, the people's Court of Shangshui County issued the decision on handling the case according to the withdrawal, announcing the withdrawal of the case.
'I used to open a small shop at the gate of the station in the county, selling tobacco, wine and non-staple food. It has been 18 years since I opened it. I usually take care of it by myself. This time, I was arrested and closed for nearly 9 months. My husband works in Guangzhou all the year round. My shop has no one to look after. Now I can't open it and can only transfer it to others, which has caused me a lot of losses. Liu Suxia told the modern express that because she was wrongly detained for 261 days (15 days of criminal detention, 258 days of imprisonment), on November 22, she filled in the application for state compensation accompanied by a lawyer, which was sent to the complaints prosecution department of the people's Procuratorate of Shangshui county and the public Security Legal Department of the Public Security Bureau of Shangshui county. Liu Suxia asked the Public Security Bureau of Shangshui county to pay 3883.35 yuan (15 days * 258.89 yuan), 150000 yuan for mental comfort and 250000 yuan for property loss during the period of illegal detention; Liu Suxia asked the procuratorate of Shangshui county to pay 63686.94 yuan (246 days * 258.89 yuan), 150000 yuan for mental comfort and 250000 yuan for property loss. The total compensation is 867570.29 yuan. Liu Suxia also asked the two organs to eliminate her influence, restore her reputation and apologize.
Liu Suxia said that in addition to applying for state compensation, she also hoped to investigate the responsibility of the investigators in accordance with the law and let Wu and his family pay the price for the false accusation and frame up. During the interview, the reporter repeatedly called the people's Procuratorate of Shangshui county to accuse the complaint prosecution department and the public security legal department of the Public Security Bureau, but there was no answer.
On November 28, Peng Qijun, a lawyer from Jiangsu nuofe law firm, told reporters in an interview that in Liu Suxia's case, before the public prosecution, evidence was collected and Wu's fracture was identified as fresh or old, which was mainly in the charge of the Public Security Bureau of Shangshui county and the people's Procuratorate of Shangshui county. Since the court finally determined that Wu's fracture belonged to an old fracture, and the procuratorate withdrew the lawsuit, the Shangshui County People's Procuratorate that originally approved Liu Suxia's arrest must bear the main responsibility. Liu Suxia is very hopeful to get state compensation. '
Peng Qijun said that in this case, Wu and his family may be suspected of false accusation and frame up, and Liu Suxia can take legal procedures to protect her rights and interests. In addition, if Wu and his family did make false evidence through the hospital and falsify their own fresh fracture, then the directly responsible person and the person in charge of the hospital will be subject to criminal punishment and may be sentenced to not more than three years' imprisonment.
The law is just and will not let go of any bad person or wronged any good person. This sentence is true, but sometimes the law will be hoodwinked by some superficial evidence. In fact, there are not a few such things in China. This is only 261 days of being wrongly shut down. Many people have been wrongly turned into murderers. Some have been locked up for more than ten or twenty years, some have been wrongly turned into murderers I was executed directly. Most of my life was ruined. Although I got the compensation from the state, can I spend my whole life? I don't know what you think about the wrong judgment and compensation? Welcome to discuss with you!