43kg girl confiscated millions of donations. Where did the money go
On January 13, the sad news came that Wu Huayan, a 43 kg college girl in Guizhou, died! Before her death, she told the cover news reporter: during the Spring Festival in 2020, she wanted to add some furniture and spend a good new year with her brother.
After the media reported Wu Huayan's story, love quickly poured in. In just five days, the treatment fund raised for Wu Huayan exceeded 1 million yuan.
In the middle, the practices of some charities, media and individuals have also been questioned by their families.
For example, why did the 9958 children's emergency relief center raise money with two fund-raising platforms without the knowledge of their families? At the same time, without the consent of Wu Huayan and her family, Wu Huayan was opened to raise funds for phase I and phase II, raising an additional 400000 yuan?
For another example, a short video account raised 450000 yuan for Wu Huayan. When Wu Huayan did not collect the money, he released a video saying that 'he has personally handed over his love to Wu Huayan'.
These moves made Wu Huayan feel cold, and also made her family lose their trust in the media and charities. Before her death, Wu Huayan stayed up all night.
How to regulate the charitable chaos of consumption sadness?
Doubt 1
Increase the fund-raising amount and charge 6% as the execution cost
Since she was hospitalized on October 12, Wu Huayan's experience has aroused great concern in the society.
At the beginning, she didn't want to ask for help online. With the encouragement of relatives and patients, she wrote help information on a platform in the hope of raising 200000 yuan to treat heart valves.
After media coverage of Wu Huayan's story, countless love poured in, many kind-hearted people rushed to the hospital to visit, and many charities took the initiative to contact her relatives.
Zhang Huiwei, deputy director of the school's party and political office, said that among them, a charity called '9958' took the initiative to contact Wu Huayan's brother and said he wanted to help them raise money.
Subsequently, the charity launched a fund-raising plan of 800000 yuan on a public welfare platform.
Starting from October 25, we raised 600443 yuan in just five days. However, Wu Huayan herself, her family and friends knew that there was a fund-raising project on the platform only after the fund-raising project was released.
Surprisingly, in addition to raising funds on this platform, '9958' has also launched two phases of love fund-raising totalling 400000 yuan on another public welfare platform.
Wu Yurong, Wu Huayan's sister, told the cover news reporter, 'Wu Huayan doesn't know about the 400000 fund-raising'.
The cover news reporter inquired about the website of China children's charity foundation and learned that '9958', the full name is
9958 children's emergency relief center is one of the projects of China children's charity relief foundation. 9958 southwest executive team is one of the executive teams of the project.
In the project information raised by 9958 children's emergency relief center for Wu Huayan, it says--
Fundraising time: October 29, 2019 - October 29, 2019.
Purpose of donation:
9958 southwest executive team hopes to raise 1 million yuan for Wu Huayan to treat the disease. At present, a public platform is adjusted for fundraising for 600 thousand, and another platform for fundraising is 20 and 200 thousand respectively.
On October 29, 9958 southwest executive team announced in the "progress report" that "considering the late treatment cost of Hua Yan and his brother's disease and other factors, we have opened phase II fund-raising on the basis of the original amount of 1 million, and the amount of 800000 on a platform has been adjusted to 600000."
On October 30, the team continued to publish in the column of "progress report". The second phase of fund-raising has been fully raised, with a total of 202338.15 yuan.
On November 1, the team explained in the 'progress report' that the above practice was because 'I believe that many people, like us, want to do something for this kind and difficult female college student & hellip& hellip;' And said, 'for this case project, 6% of the raised amount will be charged as the project implementation cost & hellip& hellip;'
Doubt 2
An organization said that '450000 yuan had been handed over to Hua Yan', and the family angrily returned 'no collection'
Wu Huayan's family and herself have repeatedly expressed their gratitude for the donation exceeding expectations.
On October 30, Wu Huayan also wrote a special statement, 'thank you for your kindness & hellip& hellip; I have raised the expected medical expenses and hereby declare that I will stop raising funds'.
However, on other side, Wu Huayan felt very guilty.
In particular, the media reported that "there is only 300 yuan per month for subsistence allowances, no breakfast, steamed bread for lunch and dinner, or bad chili bibimbap lasted for 5 years, spending almost 2 yuan per day", and the information "Wu Huayan's parents died one after another after she was 4 years old, and her grandmother died in 2017" released by 9958 emergency assistance center on the fund-raising platform kept her awake all night.
These descriptions are not completely accurate and true, nor have they been verified by Wu Huayan.
She felt sorry for helping her head teacher and classmates in high school, for helping her principals, teachers and villagers of Guizhou Shenghua Vocational College for a long time.
At 0:30 a.m., she sent a wechat to Wang Shan, who subsidized her 400 yuan a month:
'Mr. Wang, I'm sorry to touch (smear) you again. & hellip; & hellip; write me so unbearable and great & hellip; & hellip; I'm not happy. Every report goes out, my heart is like a heavy stone, which makes me out of breath & hellip; & hellip; '
At 4:40 a.m. on October 30, she sent another message to Wang Shan:
'if I didn't report a report at the beginning, I'd rather go home and wait to go to another world to complete my dream, write my poetry and live a life without sadness'.
Wu Yurong, Wu Huayan's sister, was also very worried when she saw this psychological state.
On October 31, at the suggestion of doctors, relatives and friends, Wu Huayan stated that she would not be interviewed for the time being.
This round of turmoil also makes Wu Yurong, who is busy with work and family and takes care of Wu Huayan, physically and mentally exhausted, and has doubts about some media and charities.
Tiktok account, called'XX tiktok, was raised by Wu Huayan in the name of 'Yan Yan action', using the two-dimensional code on the shaking platform, and released a video, saying that more than 45 yuan love money had been handed to Wu Huayan in person. "The" voice of the "news of the" swallow ", which is called" the news of the swallow ", is the name of the"'XX ".
But Wu Huayan and her relatives said they had not received the money.
'we didn't take the money at all. They came to the hospital, but we had enough money for love, so we confiscated it. " Wu Yurong was very angry.
In the comments above,'XX listened to news, and on October 31st introduced: "we have communicated with the flower swallow face to face tiktok today, and this money will be hit in her account as soon as possible. However, Wu Yurong does not recognize it. She believes that this behavior is suspected of 'consuming Wu Huayan and using Wu Huayan to expand eyeballs and traffic'.
Doubt 3
How to regulate charity chaos?
According to the daily 'progress' of the 9958 southwest executive team, the total amount of donations raised by the two platforms for Wu Huayan has exceeded 1 million yuan.
So why did the team raise 400000 yuan in two phases on another platform without Wu Huayan's knowledge? What is the purpose of adjusting the amount of the previous fund-raising platform? According to the provisions of the charity law, when raising money, charities should publish the personal information, contact information and office address of the person in charge. Why is there no information in the fund-raising project of 9958 emergency relief center?
Where does the 9958 southwest executive team work? Who is in charge?
At the same time, Wu Huayan herself has a grateful heart, but she doesn't know who has donated money for her, where these kind-hearted people come from and how much they have donated.
Can the 9958 southwest executive team disclose the details of donations?
At 10:45 on November 5, the cover news reporter called 9958 emergency rescue center, expecting to talk to the head of 9958 southwest implementation team, solve the doubts of netizens and their families, and listen to their explanation of netizens' questioning 'consumption of Wu Huayan'.
After the staff of 9958 emergency rescue center connected the phone, they asked the reporter to leave their contact information and said that they would contact the person in charge of 9958 southwest implementation team to contact the reporter.
But the reporter never received a reply.