Original title: what did Shanghai police say in response to the doctor's being handcuffed? The truth of the incident in which the doctor refused to cut the line and was handcuffed
The online hot spread of the incident that an expert in Renji Hospital was taken away in handcuffs by the police for refusing to receive patients who cut in line has aroused great concern among netizens. CCTV reporter asked Shanghai police for confirmation of the incident. The police reported the situation as follows:
At 15:49 on April 24, 2019, Pudong public security sub Bureau received a report from 110 police. The reporter, Chen (female, 52 years old), said that her husband was beaten by a doctor in Renji Hospital on Pujian road. After preliminary investigation, accompanied by her husband Han (male, 60 years old), Chen went to Renji Hospital (East Hospital) for registration at about 10:30 am on the same day according to doctor Zhao's previous appointment. At about 12:50, doctor Zhao (male, 48 years old) visited the doctor. Due to the need to transfer the CT film previously taken, both parties agreed to come to see the doctor again at 15:30. At about 15:20 on the same day, Han entered the consulting room to look for a doctor and was told to wait for treatment. About 10 minutes later, Han once again asked the doctor to treat his wife, Zhao informed him to continue waiting. Han Jianzhi refuses to leave, and has a verbal dispute with Zhao. Zhao wants to push Han out of the clinic, and the two sides then have a physical conflict.
According to the police officer Chen, who accused his husband of being beaten by Zhao, the police on the scene had a preliminary understanding that physical conflicts did occur between the two sides, and found that there were many obvious scars on Han. In order to further carry out the investigation, the on-site disposal police, according to the relevant provisions of the law on public security management punishment, asked the doctor involved Zhao to go to the police station to cooperate with the investigation. Zhao refused to go to the police station for reception and meeting, causing other medical staff, patients and family members to watch. In order to prevent the escalation of contradictions, the police first took Han and his wife to the police station for investigation. After waiting for Zhao to continue the treatment for about 20 minutes, the police proposed that the hospital arrange other doctors to continue the treatment, but Zhao refused. The police then summoned Zhao verbally and forced him to leave the clinic after Zhao refused. When forced to leave the waiting hall, Zhao had physical conflict with the police. To this end, the police will use handcuffs to summon Zhao to the police station for investigation.
Experience injury, Han's right 10th rib fracture, right 9th and 11th rib suspected of bone fracture, Zhao's upper limb and right lateral neck soft tissue contusion. At present, the case is under further investigation.
In conclusion:
1、 It is not consistent with the fact that Chen, a patient of Internet transmission, cut in the queue unreasonably. The patient, Chen, made an appointment for treatment, registered normally with doctor Zhao, and came to see the doctor according to the appointment time. Those who didn't pass on the Internet cut in the queue unreasonably.
2、 It is inconsistent with the fact that the doctor involved in the online transmission maintains the order of medical treatment, is not suspected of breaking the law, and is directly taken away by the police with handcuffs. On the basis of the preliminary investigation of the causes of the dispute, the fact of the physical conflict between the two sides, and the injury of the patient's family member, the on-site disposal of the police is based on the suspected violation of the law by the involved doctor Zhao, who is verbally summoned to cooperate with the investigation, and is directly taken away in handcuffs without online transmission.
3、 In the case of Zhao's refusal to cooperate and physical conflict with the police, the use of handcuffs on the scene for compulsory summons is in line with the legal provisions such as the provisions on the procedures of public security organs for handling administrative cases.