Why do organ donation in Vietnam cause controversy? What is the truth

according to Vietnamese media on July 16, an 18-year-old Nguyen surnamed man in Ho Chi Minh City was sentenced to death by the court for killing five people. After his sentence, the man said he wanted to donate organs, but the incident caused heated discussion among Vietnamese netizens. Why is it controversial? What is the truth? Let's take a look

Vietnam Youth Daily conducted an online vote on whether to agree with the donation of organs by the death penalty criminals. The voting results showed that the number of people who agreed with and against the donation accounted for half of the total. The objection is that the death penalty is imposed on the death penalty for the cruel illegal act, and the person who accepts the organs of the death penalty will have psychological shadow. The supporters said that the donation of organs by the death penalty criminals is a kind act, and their criminal behavior is caused by education and social environment, and has nothing to do with their organs. According to reports, there are no legal restrictions on the donation of organs by death penalty criminals, but because of the way of lethal injection in Vietnam, drugs will affect the function of organs, so the value of transplantation is not high.

Nearly 300000 people in china volunteer to register organ donation 'Chinese model' has won international praise

On August 6, 2017, the reporter learned yesterday from the 2017 National Conference on human organ donation and transplantation that the number of voluntary registration of human organ donation in China is nearly 300000, and the number of completed organ donation cases has exceeded 12000. In the first seven months of this year, China completed 2866 donations, a year-on-year increase of 33%, achieving leapfrog development. China's organ transplantation technology and quality have reached the international advanced level, and the standardized, fair and efficient system has been praised internationally.

"Improve the quality of life, save people's lives and promote health and well-being. Guo Yanhong, deputy director of the state health and Family Planning Commission, said that organ donation and transplantation in China is an important part of people's health. Since 2015, China has successfully realized the transformation of organ source, and all transplanted organs come from the voluntary donation of social citizens.

Five years ago, a peasant girl named Wen Wen died of illness. Her kidney, liver, heart and cornea were donated to six strangers. This year's Qingming Festival, Wenwen's mother, Xu Mengxian, received a special gift -- the heartbeat from the recipient patients. Xu Mengxian said: 'I'm glad to hear my daughter Wen's heartbeat. Plus the man's letter that he's doing well, that's good & hellip; & hellip; '

In 2010, there were only 34 donors who donated human organs free of charge, like Wen Wen. In 2016, there were 4080 donors, ranking second in the world. Guo Yanhong said that not only the number of donors has leaped, but also the quality of organ transplantation and the survival rate of patients are among the world's leading indicators.

"After nearly 10 years of exploration and reform, China has embarked on a path of organ donation and transplantation that not only reflects international practices, but also combines China's specific national conditions, forming the" Chinese model "of human organ donation and transplantation;. "Huang Jiefu, chairman of China human organ donation and Transplantation Committee, said that China has comprehensively constructed the legal framework of organ donation and transplantation at the national level, and established the five major scientific working systems of organ donation and transplantation led by the government and participated by many parties.

The top-level design of legalization and standardization makes life continue in the sunshine. The national health and Family Planning Commission and the Red Cross have successively issued more than 30 supporting policy documents. In 2007, the State Council promulgated the regulations on human organ transplantation, which clearly defined the source of organ donation and the right of citizens to donate organs, and made qualification provisions for relevant medical institutions and medical personnel. In 2013, the national health and Family Planning Commission issued regulations on the administration of organ acquisition and distribution of human donation (Trial), to ensure the transparency, fairness and traceability of organ acquisition and donation.

According to the data, by 2017, there were 173 hospitals with organ transplantation qualification in China. In an interview with reporters, Matti & middot maarritch, President of the international organ donation and acquisition Association, said that increasing organ transplant professionals at the level of medical institutions, strengthening the construction of relevant infrastructure capacity and improving the quality control system are common challenges facing China and other countries around the world. "Next, we hope that China will strengthen international cooperation in medical experts, technical training and other fields, and contribute to the global organ donation and transplantation & lsquo; Chinese strength & rsquo;. "Said Nancy middot Escher, President of the international organ transplant association.