(December 5), the intermediate people's Court of Yulin City, Shaanxi Province pronounced a judgment in the first instance of the murder of a 15-year-old girl in Shenmu, and six defendants were sentenced. One of them committed the crime of intentional homicide and forced prostitution and was sentenced to life imprisonment. The victim's family members expressed dissatisfaction with the result of the judgment and will appeal.
Two months after the girl left home, her body was found, and the suspects were six minors
According to the Beijing News, Liu Yu (pseudonym), a 15-year-old girl from Shenmu, Yulin, Shaanxi Province, left home in September 2018. Two months later, Liu Yu's body was found. The family received police news that Liu Yu was asked by six minors for prostitution, beaten to death, dismembered and buried. The Beijing News reporter confirmed to the police that the incident was true.
On September 19 this year, Yulin intermediate people's court heard the case in Shenmu court. Liu Yu's mother told the Beijing news that the family decided to give up the civil compensation request and demanded that the murderer be severely punished.
Today (December 5), Yulin intermediate people's court announced the judgment of the first instance of the case. The court held that the defendants Yang, Bai, Zhang, he and Qiao forced the victim into prostitution and beat the victim for a long time, resulting in his death, and his behavior constituted the crime of intentional homicide; The defendant Yang forced Li into prostitution, which also constituted the crime of forced prostitution; The defendant Zhang mouhao collaborated with others to rob property, and his behavior also constituted the crime of robbery; The defendant Li mouwei colluded with others to steal and help others dismember the body. His behavior constituted the crime of theft and helping to destroy evidence. The public prosecution was charged and convicted.
6. The circumstances of the defendant's crime were extremely bad and the consequences were extremely serious. He continued to commit the crime after killing and dismembering the body. His subjective malignancy was deep and should be punished according to law. The defendant Yang was under the age of 16 when he committed the crime of intentional homicide and under the age of 18 when he committed the crime of forced prostitution; The defendants Bai mouhe, He Mou, Zhang mouhao and Qiao mouguo were under the age of 16 when they committed the crime; The defendant Li mouwei, who was under the age of 18 when he committed the crime, shall be given a lighter punishment according to law.
In an incidental civil action, the plaintiff appealed for civil compensation to support the funeral expenses according to law. The defendant Yang's defender argued that the acts of Yang and others should be identified as the crime of intentional injury. After investigation, Yang and others continued to beat the victim, and Bai mouhe hit him on the head. He held a laissez faire attitude towards the death of the victim and should be identified as the crime of intentional homicide, which was not accepted. The defender of the defendant Zhang mouhao held that Zhang mouhao forcibly seized other people's property; If the circumstances are minor, he may not be convicted and punished for robbery. After investigation, Zhang mouhao has been exempted from criminal investigation before robbery, and he is not an accidental offender. His robbery shall be convicted and punished.
Each defender believed that each defendant was a juvenile crime and should be given a lighter punishment, which was adopted by the court. The defenders of Yang, Zhang and Li believed that the defendant had confessed to the crime, which was verified and given a lighter punishment as appropriate. The defenders of the defendants he and Zhang believed that they were accomplices. After investigation, he took the initiative to contact the victim, and the two took the initiative in beating the victim. In this case, there is no distinction between the principal and subordinate, so the defense opinion is not accepted.
Six defendants were sentenced, one of whom was sentenced to life imprisonment
The court ruled as follows: the defendant Yang committed the crime of intentional homicide, sentenced to life imprisonment, committed the crime of forced prostitution, sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of seven years and fined 5000 yuan, and decided to execute life imprisonment and fined 5000 yuan.
The defendant Bai mouhe committed the crime of intentional homicide and was sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of 15 years. The defendant He Mou committed the crime of intentional homicide and was sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of 14 years.
The defendant Zhang mouhao committed the crime of intentional homicide and was sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of 12 years; If he commits the crime of robbery, he shall be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of one year and a fine of 2000 yuan. It is decided that he shall be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of 12 years and 8 months and a fine of 2000 yuan.
The defendant Qiao mouguo committed intentional homicide and was sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of 11 years. Li mouwei committed theft and was sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of 10 months and a fine of 2000 yuan; Whoever commits the crime of helping to destroy evidence shall be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of three years, and the combined decision shall be executed with fixed-term imprisonment of three years and six months and a fine of 2000 yuan.
The legal representatives of the defendants Yang Mou, Bai Mou he, Zhang Mou Hao, He Mou, Qiao Mou Guo and Li Mou Wei compensated 35591.3 yuan for the economic loss of the plaintiff in the incidental civil action, and were jointly and severally liable to each other. Reject other claims of the plaintiff in incidental civil action.
At about 13:00, Liu Yu's mother told the Beijing news that the family members were not satisfied with the verdict and would appeal.
Family members said that their daughter has not been buried so far, hoping that the prostitute will be investigated for criminal responsibility
More than a year has passed since the incident. Liu Yu's parents said that they still can't sleep a whole night. 'they didn't sleep until 12 o'clock and woke up at 1 or 2 o'clock.' Liu Yu's father said that now the things about Liu Yu at home have been put away and try not to mention Liu Yu. His wife's mental state has been bad and depressed. He has been running around for the case. His son has the best relationship with his sister Liu Yu. After the incident, his son became silent and his grades fell a lot.
Liu Yu's mother believed that the six defendants were sentenced in the first instance, and the client Han involved in the case should also be punished. She believes that Han Moumou asked for prostitution, and Liu Yu was taken to the hotel to have a relationship with him. Then Han Moumou found an excuse to refuse to pay the fee, causing a contradiction, resulting in Liu Yu's death after being beaten. Han Moumou should also be listed as an accomplice and subject to criminal punishment.
Previously, in an interview with surging news, the staff of Wanzhen town government of Shenmu city said that in December 2018, the relevant departments of Wanzhen Town People's government had received the notice of termination of investigation issued by Shenmu Public Security Bureau, which said that Han was suspected of rape, but after investigation, it did not constitute a crime, so they decided to terminate the investigation.
The staff member said that Han had worked in the people's Government of Wanzhen Town, Shenmu City, but he was not a public official, 'just a coordinator', and Han had left in the spring of 2019. It is understood that after the incident, Han was detained by the local police for 15 days and fined 5000 yuan.
Liu Yu's mother didn't agree with the above response. She said that since her daughter's accident, their husband and wife didn't go out to work again, and there was no income at home. Liu Yu has not been buried yet, and he has been placed in the funeral home, which is expensive. 'it takes hundreds of people a day, and he has been in the funeral home for more than a year. Han Moumou also did not receive the punishment he should have, hoping to save the child's final dignity. " Source: Beijing News