(original title: chaos in medical beauty industry)
The chaos in the medical and beauty industry has reached the point where those plastic surgery experts and academic celebrities can't bear it. On October 30, when the "special research group on medical beauty industry" organized by the people's Political Consultative newspaper and led by sun Xianze, deputy director of the education, science, health and Sports Committee of the 13th CPPCC National Committee and chairman of the Chinese Pharmaceutical Association, came to the Ninth People's Hospital Affiliated to the Medical College of Shanghai Jiaotong University, some experts from the Ninth People's hospital came down from the clinic wearing masks and some came out of the operating room wearing coveralls, Others hold a thick stack of written materials sorted out late, and they want to 'reflect the problem'.
In August last year, the 2018 white paper on the medical beauty industry released by a private medical beauty organization showed that the scale of China's medical beauty market may reach 224.5 billion yuan in 2018. The white paper also shows that there are more than 100000 illegal studios and beauty salons in China's medical and beauty market. The "China Medical Beauty 'underground black needle' white paper" released by China data research center and China Plastic Surgery Association reveals amazing information about 'black doctors'. The data show that in the' black medical beauty 'market, there are 9' black doctors' in every 10 medical beauty practitioners.
3000 yuan can be a 'medical beauty consultant', and 230000 yuan a shot of vitamin C can be sold to consumers
'3000 yuan for a month, you can get a practicing qualification certificate of medical beauty consultant. These consultants sell cosmetics, clothes and restaurants. They advise you how you should have plastic surgery. " Sun Baoshan, director of plastic surgery of Shanghai No. 9 hospital, has done medical quality monitoring for 18 years and has been in the front line of medical beauty quality monitoring. He told reporters that the so-called "medical beauty consultant" business is damaging the young "regular army" doctors and destroying the ecology of the whole industry.
According to the official interpretation of the medical cosmetology and cosmetology branch of the Chinese Medical Association, medical beauty consultants are practitioners engaged in consulting work in beauty and plastic institutions and build a communication bridge between plastic surgeons and beauty seekers. The certification of beauty medical consultants refers to other national professional qualification certification methods. The qualification certification mainly includes two parts: training and assessment.
However, when you search the keyword 'beauty medical consultant' on the Internet, you can see that the 'regular army' can hardly be found. On the contrary, you can see that 'Tina teacher' who graduated from a university majoring in medical beauty teaches you how to improve your taste by drawing every day and serve 20 customers a day; You can see the "secret door" for medical and American institutions to recruit consultants. Pointing directly at consultants is the essence of "customer service + sales"; You can see the recruitment advertisement of the so-called professional license issuing agency, and you can get a license in a month's intensive training; You can also see the 'magic' recruitment advertisement of 'base salary 500 + subsidy 500 + commission' issued by the organization, but can earn more than 10000 yuan per month.
"The medical and beauty industry has now become an industry with extremely poor technical quality. Barber shops, beauty salons and foot therapy shops can do medical and beauty as long as they are brave enough." Sun Baoshan said that the threshold of the medical and beauty industry is low and the market is large. Many 'bosses' flock to it,' if you do a bad job, you can have civil liability at most, earn 1 million and lose 200000, which is worth it. '
Sun Baoshan has seen some private medical and beauty institutions make 'beauty needles' with vitamin C, normal saline and vitamin B12, and then sell them to consumers at the price of 230000 yuan a needle; I've also seen the 'strange thing' that someone paid for opening a double eyelid with an offer of 100000 yuan. " I've seen a lot. It's not uncommon in the medical and beauty industry for a long time. " Sun Baoshan said.
Luan Jie, vice president of the plastic surgery hospital of the Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences and chairman of the plastic surgery branch of the Chinese Medical Association, also noticed this' strange thing '.' many private medical institutions are rich and dirty. Among them, they spend a lot of money on stores and doors, with luxurious decoration, but the wires and needles used in the operating room are the cheapest. If the drainage tube can be replaced by an infusion set, the drainage tube must not be used '.
Doctors in cardiology and orthopedics became plastic surgeons after short-term training
An unnamed plastic surgeon told reporters that one of his friends in the same department 'changed jobs' to a private plastic institution under the temptation of high salary not long ago. This is a fairly formal private organization. The plastic surgeons it employs are professionals with professional qualifications in the plastic surgery department. But there, doctors live a 'mixed life'.
'at first, the consultant sister recommended the patient to him. He made preoperative analysis and judgment as seriously as he did in a public hospital, and then declined the patient because he did not meet the surgical indications. " The doctor said that after several times, the doctor from the 'regular army' was' blocked 'by the consultant,' all consultants do not recommend patients to him, & lsquo; Hungry & rsquo; He can't do an operation in three months. " Finally, the young doctor compromised. He no longer dared to 'decline' patients recommended by consultants.
China Youth Daily & middot; The reporter of China Youth Network noted that the former Ministry of Health issued the measures for the administration of medical beauty services (order 19) in 2002, which clearly stipulates that the 'attending doctor' responsible for the implementation of medical beauty projects must be a 'licensed doctor', which mentioned that the licensed doctor must 'have received professional training or further study in medical beauty and be qualified, or have been engaged in clinical work of medical beauty for more than one year'. However, in the face of huge interest temptation, doctors in cardiology, orthopedics and other departments have become plastic surgeons after short-term training.
Wang Danru, deputy director of plastic surgery and director of the Organization Department of Shanghai No. 9 hospital, noted that the young doctors who come to the hospital for regular training and specialized training are different from the past. 'doctors should be the industry of saving the lives and healing the wounded. Now many doctors are occupied by the huge medical and beauty market and specialize in cosmetic surgery rather than facial repair'.
The "regular army" is in great shortage
Luan Jie said, 'chasing huge profits' has now become a hard injury for private medical and beauty institutions. Now many medical institutions call patients' customers',' this is unique in the world, and many countries call it & lsquo; Patient & rsquo. In the medical beauty industry, 'medical essence' has now been diluted, 'many institutions try to replace it with service and aesthetics, including some experts who believe that aesthetics is a system and should gradually break away from the medical specialty of plastic surgery'.
Luan Jie's research found that many private institutions' spend money to buy certificates', and the state stipulates that there must be doctors with doctor practice qualification certificates in institutions. Therefore, these institutions spend thousands of yuan a month to hire a certified retired doctor, 'doctors don't have to come to work at all, they just need to have certificates and deal with examinations'.
In addition, the current "regular army" of plastic surgeons is scarce. Xiao ran, member of the CPPCC National Committee and director of the research center of the plastic surgery hospital (Badachu plastic hospital) of the Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences, has repeatedly called for the establishment of a "specialist system".
Luan Jie suggested that the medical beauty industry must determine the 'leading position and mechanism of public hospitals', and should fall on the' shoulders' of public hospitals from doctor training to system construction and diagnosis and treatment norms. At the same time, the government should also give public hospitals sufficient operating mechanism space, 'just let them train and formulate norms, but the people they train go to private institutions, and they can't keep people.'
Li Shengli, deputy director of plastic surgery of Shanghai Ninth Hospital, suggested that the revised 'order 19' should encourage qualified doctors to set up private medical and American institutions independently or jointly, 'a boss who knows nothing can open as long as he has money, which is wrong. A doctor who has been trained by a scientific class has a minimum sense of professional honor '.