Sihai network

How dare the shopkeeper claim compensation for running away from overlord meal

How dare the shopkeeper claim compensation for running away from overlord meal

A group of people ate supper after singing karaoke, but they left collectively after dinner. Seeing that the boss and his wife came one after another, one of the men fell when he escaped and sued the restaurant owner for 40000 yuan. Recently, the court of Fancheng District, Xiangyang City, Hubei Province disclosed that after the first and second instance of the case, it was finally determined that the restaurant owner should not pay compensation.

court:

There is no basis in the situation, reason and law

According to the judgment of China referee network, the incident occurred in Fancheng District, Xiangyang City, Hubei Province. In the early morning of April 3, 2018, after singing in a KTV on Hanjiang Road, Zhang Jun and his party went to a restaurant on Hanjiang Road for supper.

At about 2:30 a.m., the group finished eating. When the clerk was not prepared, six people left the restaurant quickly without saying hello to the boss and clerk and checking out. When the landlady Wang Fang found out, she immediately went out to recover the meal expenses, shouted and asked them to pay the bill. Zhang Jun and others did not stop when they heard the cry, but quickly dispersed and left.

Because Zhang Jun was closest to Wang Fang, Wang Fang chased him all the way and called the police and her husband Gao Qiang. Zhang Jun heard Wang Fang call the police and wanted to take a taxi to leave. Wang Fang came forward and grabbed Zhang Jun, so Zhang Jun had to run forward.

After Gao Qiang arrived, Zhang Jun was afraid of being caught and rushed forward desperately. When he ran to the intersection of Songhe Road, he fell and was injured. Gao Qiang also fell while chasing. Later, the police arrived, asked Zhang Jun to go to the hospital for treatment, and took Wang Fang to the police station for questioning.

Zhang Jun was hospitalized for 11 days and spent 6848 yuan. After identification, the degree of injury belongs to grade II of minor injury. After leaving the hospital, Zhang Jun took Wang Fang and his wife to court and asked them to compensate for their medical expenses.

After hearing, the people's Court of Fancheng District, Xiangyang City, Hubei Province held that Zhang Jun and his party had dinner in the second defendant's store and should take the initiative to pay the meal fee after eating. However, Zhang Jun and his party left on their own without saying hello or checking out after dinner, which was a subjective fault.

Wang Fang found that after Zhang Jun and his party left without checking out, in order to protect their own rights and interests, they went out to catch up with Zhang Jun and others at the intersection of Songhe road and Hanjiang Road, and asked Zhang Jun and others to check out, but Zhang Jun and others still refused to pay and walked away, which was worse subjectively.

Seeing that Zhang Jun and others refused to settle the bill, Wang Fang called 110 first and then called Gao Qiang to seek multi-party assistance. It was handled properly without any fault.

Zhang Jun wanted to escape when he saw Gao Qiang's pursuit. He fell and was injured in the process of escape. The two defendants had no physical contact with Zhang Jun, no infringement, no fault, and should not be liable.

Zhang Jun asked the two defendants to compensate them for their medical expenses, totaling 40760.32 yuan. It should be rejected because it is incompatible with the situation, unreasonable and groundless in the law.

The court of first instance ruled that the plaintiff Zhang Jun's claim was rejected; The case acceptance fee is 500 yuan, halved and charged 250 yuan, which shall be borne by the plaintiff Zhang Jun. Zhang Jun refused to accept the judgment and appealed, and the original judgment was upheld in the second instance. (the party is a pseudonym)

Netizen: villains complain first

@My face fell to the ground while running

@66 cans of Kiwi sauce: real villains complain first

@Yan Zhongwen's essay: in this era, there are also people who eat overlord food

@Inch medicine burning Jing: this porcelain doesn't have any technical content

@Donghai xiaogongju: what about the other five? You should sue them. All you know is that you should share the risk of falling! In other words, buy the order first